In brief
- Bitcoin ETF shares can be created or redeemed by authorized participants without requiring instant purchases or sales of Bitcoin on public exchanges.
- Analysts say derivatives hedging and settlement timing can weaken the short-term link between ETF inflows and spot price movements.
- The mechanics are legal and widespread across ETF market makers, but may shift price discovery toward futures markets during periods of heavy institutional flow.
Bitcoin’s Wednesday rally has reignited debate over the role of Wall Street market makers in spot Bitcoin exchange-traded funds, after online speculation linked the price move to a lawsuit involving quantitative trading firm and liquidity provider Jane Street.
Posts circulating on X claimed that Bitcoin’s roughly 10% climb over two days coincided with the disappearance of a purported intraday selling pattern, suggesting that legal action against Jane Street had altered market behaviour.
Analysts and ETF specialists, however, said the focus on a single firm obscures a more complex set of market mechanics underlying how spot Bitcoin ETFs operate.
Bitcoin ETFs track the asset’s spot price, but the creation and redemption process allows institutional middlemen to meet demand without having to buy or sell Bitcoin on public exchanges.
Jeff Park, chief investment officer at ProCap and an adviser to ETF issuer Bitwise, said Wednesday the debate reflects a misunderstanding of ETF market structure rather than evidence of manipulation.
In a screenshot post on X, Park outlined how large trading firms responsible for creating and redeeming ETF shares, known as authorized participants, operate under regulatory exemptions that allow them to meet ETF demand without mechanically forcing immediate spot Bitcoin purchases.
Park said those exemptions, which apply to all authorized participants, are designed to support orderly ETF market-making, but can create a “grey window” in which ETF share creation, hedging activity, and spot market transactions are not tightly linked in time.
As a result, ETF inflows do not always translate into immediate buying pressure in the spot Bitcoin market, weakening the assumption that ETF demand directly maps to spot price movements.
Ryan McMillin, chief investment officer at crypto fund manager Merkle Tree Capital, told Decrypt the structure also creates incentives that favour derivatives over spot markets.
Because Bitcoin futures frequently trade at a premium to spot prices in a condition known as contango, authorized participants may hedge exposure using futures while earning carry from the basis, he said.
“ETF assets under management balloons without forcing exchange buys, muting rallies below key levels where hype would otherwise push prices higher in a flywheel,” McMillin said.
McMillin added that when futures positions are reduced, either due to macro shifts or narrowing spreads, the adjustment can amplify price swings, contributing to sharp pullbacks that appear sudden to retail investors.
Both analysts stressed that the behaviour is legal and consistent with how ETFs are designed to operate, and does not imply wrongdoing by any individual firm.
Instead, they said it highlights how Bitcoin’s price discovery is increasingly shaped by institutional trading venues such as futures markets, rather than spot exchanges alone.
“APs wield hedge-fund-like incentives and tools with less accountability in a volatile, adoption-stage asset,” McMillin said. “The ETF ‘innovation’ risks becoming a yield-skimming machine for Wall St. that prioritises institutional arbitrage over genuine spot support.”
Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to
Disclaimer.
Related Articles
Zonda Exchange CEO Blames Missing Founder for $336M in Lost Bitcoin
Zonda CEO Przemysław Kral has attributed the exchange's loss of access to 4,500 BTC, valued at $336 million, to missing founder Sylwester Suszek's failure to transfer private keys. Amid allegations of bankruptcy and intensified withdrawal requests, Kral insists Zonda remains solvent and will pursue legal action while searching for Suszek, who disappeared in 2022.
GateNews1h ago
BTC drops 0.52% in 15 minutes: Whale inflows to exchanges combined with insufficient liquidity amplify sell pressure
From 2026-04-17 10:15 to 2026-04-17 10:30 (UTC), the BTC price rapidly fell within the 75214.3 – 75725.9 USDT range. The cumulative return over 15 minutes was -0.52%, and the amplitude reached 0.68%. During this period, market sentiment shifted from cautious to bearish, volatility on the board increased, mainstream trading pairs saw an increase in主动 sell-side volume, buy-side acceptance became constrained, and overall trading activity declined significantly.
The primary driver behind this unusual move is that large holders (whales) concentrated their short-term inflows into exchanges. On-chain data shows that net inflows to addresses holding more than 1000 BTC per address changed from a steady state to a positive value, directly boosting exchange balances over the short term. Historical data indicates that whale inflows to exchanges are highly correlated with sell pressure in the medium to short term. In the same period, order book snapshots reflected a significant increase in the volume of主动 sell orders, and the成交价梯度 shifted downward, highlighting that weak market absorption capacity caused a short-term drop in price.
In addition, in the derivatives market, the long/short positioning structure tilted toward shorts. The number of主动 sell contracts exceeded that of buys in a short time, and rising pressure to close long positions further intensified the downtrend. Market liquidity overall was relatively weak; the number of active addresses over the past 10 minutes was only about 42k, and both fees and the mempool were near their lowest levels of the recent month. Against a backdrop of insufficient capital absorption, the marginal impact of large sell orders was amplified. On the macro front, the Federal Reserve’s monetary policy tightening and industry media repeatedly downgraded BTC’s near-term expectations led investors’ risk appetite to generally decline, creating a resonance at the level of market sentiment.
In the short term, it is still necessary to stay alert to liquidity risk and the price impact of one-way large transactions in specific trading pairs. Going forward, focus on key developments such as changes in whales’ on-chain holdings, exchange balances, and rebounds in activity metrics, as well as the potential impact of macro policy direction on risk assets. Relevant users should primarily guard against the risk of sharply amplified short-term price volatility and promptly track more market information.
GateNews1h ago
Bitcoin Developers Propose Freezing Coins That Skip Quantum-Safe Migration Under BIP-361
A draft proposal circulating among Bitcoin developers would give holders roughly five years to move their coins to quantum-resistant addresses or watch them become permanently unspendable on the network.
Key Takeaways:
BIP-361, co-authored by Casa CTO Jameson Lopp, proposes freezing Bitcoin in le
Coinpedia2h ago
BTC slides 0.70% in the short term: On-chain fund outflows and derivatives deleveraging align to weigh on the market
Between 09:30 and 09:45 (UTC) on 2026-04-17, the BTC price’s return within 15 minutes was -0.70%. During the day, it fluctuated in the 75511.9 to 76307.6 USDT range, with an amplitude of 1.04%. Short-term market sentiment became more cautious; although capital activity increased, volatility noticeably accelerated.
The main driving force behind this move is the large-scale outflow of funds on-chain and active deleveraging in the derivatives market. On-chain data shows that, within this time window, the net outflow from BTC exchanges increased, with a 24-hour net outflow of -2,844.68 BTC. Investors transferred a large amount of BTC to cold wallets, significantly weakening market liquidity and pressuring buy-side demand, which dragged prices lower. In the derivatives space, open interest in perpetual contracts fell in tandem; some leveraged funds actively reduced exposure, indicating the market’s more conservative stance on short-term price action, thereby further weakening support.
In addition, multiple large transfers and whale address activity occurred frequently during the anomaly period, amplifying pressure on capital flows and causing sentiment in the derivatives market to turn even colder. The funding rate dropped briefly within the window, indirectly reflecting that some position holders moved into cold wallets for safer risk management. At the same time, the number of active addresses remained persistently high at over 120k, suggesting network participation was not hit and the fundamentals remained stable; however, the combined effect of frequent outflows amplified market volatility in the short term.
What needs to be watched is that continuous net outflows of funds on-chain and a decline in holdings pose a threat to the stability of support levels. Large address behavior could lead to further capital escaping. In the short term, focus on changes in exchange BTC balances, on-chain transfer volumes, whale address flow, and the dynamics of derivatives open interest. If capital does not return later, volatility risk may further expand; it is recommended to closely monitor real-time market conditions and key on-chain indicators.
GateNews2h ago
The U.S. vetoes the Iran-war powers resolution, while the BTC price trades in a range near $75,000
On April 17, Bitcoin traded in a tight range near $75,500. The U.S. vetoed a war-powers resolution against Iran, while Israel and Lebanon reached a 10-day ceasefire—geopolitical signals moved in opposite directions. Institutional fund inflows coexisted with outflows on-chain; Bitcoin’s correlation with the Nasdaq briefly turned negative—leaving the market waiting for a breakout in either direction.
GateInstantTrends2h ago
BTC breaks through 76000 USDT
Gate News bot message, Gate market data shows that BTC has broken through 76000 USDT, with the current price at 76188.7 USDT.
CryptoRadar2h ago
